May 14, 2008

Voter ID: The Hound That Didn't Bark

Apparently Indiana's voter ID law prevented 12 nuns from voting. Is this really the best that opponents of the law could muster?!

Oh, those poor nuns!

I realize (and often point out in various contexts!) that absence of evidence is not necessarily evidence of absence. But still, a thought experiment:

Which of these are you more likely to hear about, if true?

A. Someone was prevented from casting a legitimate vote.
B. Someone was prevented from casting a fraudulent vote.

Posted by Matt Bruce at May 14, 2008 06:05 PM
What Other People Say

Actually, nuns are a pretty damn good case for them to muster. Who wants to argue to keep nuns from voting? It doesn't get better than that.

In 2006, a congresswoman from Indiana couldn't vote because she didn't have her ID with her, but she presumably came back later. Same for a Republican congressman from Ohio. There's also an old African-American woman in St. Louis, where the state is proposing people bring proof of citizenship to the polls, who says her home state of Mississippi has no record of a birth certificate so she's SOL for proving she was born her.

There are a lot of PR-ready people out there for this.

Posted by: M.S at May 15, 2008 07:41 AM

Born "here," ha, that's a good typo.

Posted by: M.S. at May 15, 2008 07:41 AM
Talk At Me









Remember personal info?